NHS Confed's issues with Personal Budgets and Integrated Care

  • Like many health systems around the world, the NHS struggles to find ways of delivering integrated care. Nowhere has this struggle been more evident than in services cutting across the health-social care divide: a decades-old problem that has, for the most part, confounded local and national leaders.

    This Briefing introduces joint personal budgets for health and social care. It gives the context behind their development, explains how they might work and lists some of the issues that need to be considered before they could be used at scale.

    Interest in how to better join up health and social care has reached a peak in recent years, with particular focus since the passage of the Health and Social Care Act 2012.

    Various solutions have been tried and tested in recent years - local area partnerships, joint financing arrangements, care trusts and now health and well-being boards.

    The direction of travel for personal budgets in social care is much clearer than in health. Local authorities have been giving personal budgets to social care users for many years. There are now more than 338,000 people in England who have one (representing almost £1 in every £7 spent by councils on care and support).

    The distinction between health and social care makes little sense to the individual service user, whose needs cannot be easily categorised into two separate groups. Given that even front-line staff also have trouble understanding the distinction between health and social care, it may be too much to expect service users to do so if they have more than one type of need and, therefore, potentially more than one budget. Evaluations of personal budgets have shown that some individuals can benefit from taking control of their care, but few will want to do this if the separate processes make no sense to them.

    Joint health and social care personal budgets may offer the chance to create a simplified process for service users to navigate. If the two systems’ separate assessments, plans, accounts and reviews can be successfully brought together, service users are less likely to feel that the burdens of controlling their own care outweigh the benefits. It could also allow service users to make purchasing decisions based on what best suits all their needs, rather than having to spend one budget on something to help their ‘health’ needs and another on their ‘social’ needs. The goal is for integrated commissioning and provision at a micro level.

    In previous papers, the NHS Confederation has identified a number of barriers that stand in the way of personal health budgets having a positive impact on NHS patients. We support the Department of Health’s proposal to introduce personal health budgets at a pace determined by commissioners. We also support the suggestion to start with continuing healthcare, which is a relatively self-contained part of healthcare that may be exempt from some of the risks we believe personal health budgets might pose. As one of the most blurred boundaries between the NHS and social care, continuing healthcare is an ideal test-bed in which to develop joint personal budgets.

    However, a number of issues remain that will need to be resolved if the potential benefits of joint personal budgets are to be realised. The NHS Confederation have requested all of your views on the issues below, to guide their future work on this topic.

    Issues to consider:

    1. Does the ‘dual carriageway’ approach described in this paper (see page 4) offer a viable way to introduce joint personal budgets at scale?

    2. How big a barrier will top ups and self-funding in social care be to integrating two systems of personal budgets?

    3. How acceptable would it be for treatments not traditionally commissioned by the NHS to receive funding through a joint personal budget?

    4. How would your staff react to the idea of joint personal budgets? What kinds of engagement and/or workforce development would be needed?

    5. What questions would you want to put to the pilot sites that have been trialling joint personal budgets?

    6. Do you agree with the NHS Confederation’s support for the Department of Health’s intention – subject to the national evaluation – to make personal health budgets a legal option for all NHS commissioners from October, and from 2014 to give people on NHS continuing healthcare a right to request a personal budget?

    Source: NHS Confed

     

     Image source: http://www.morguefile.com/archive/display/200384

     

     

     

Related articles

  • Read More

    Adults with vulnerabilities in custody are not receiving appropriate support

    A report commissioned by the Home Office has said that lack of awareness and a shortage of trained volunteers means police often go ahead without on present, reports the BBC.Home Secretary Theresa...

  • Read More

    Chief inspector warns cuts are affecting adult social care

    Andrea Sutcliffe has said that many carers ended up being "the sort of care worker you wouldn't want them to be", reports the BBC.Adult social care budgets have been cut by £4.6bn since 2010 - a 31%...

  • Read More

    Social care services for adults struggling due to budget cuts

    There is a £1.1.bn shortfall to councils in England warns the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, and freezing care provider fees to save money is no longer sustainable, reports the...

  • Read More

    People with vulnerabilities left at risk by policy makers

    ‘Solutions from the Frontline’, published by a coalition of charities looks into the ideas and experiences of service users. It investigates how the new government along with national and local...

  • Read More

    Social landlords in Wales hope to save the NHS £1.7m

    The savings will come from housing 33 patients under the care of the Aneurin Bevan University health board, through a project called ‘In One Place.' This project places patients who have a mental...

  • Read More

    New supported housing service for people needing care after hospital

    The service will provide supported accommodation for people who no longer need specialist medical care, but who are no longer able to return home due to changes in their home care needs. It is hoped...

  • Read More

    Proposal for an extension on the integration of health and social care in Staffordshire

    Staffordshire County Council wishes to agree on a new deal which will help to improve integration between health and social care for its residents, reports ITV.The deal, if agreed, will extend the...

  • Read More

    Older people and people with disabilities finding it hard to get state funded care

    Social services leaders are warning that many people with disabilities or older people with care needs are facing the challenge of having to pay for their own support at the end of the next...

  • Read More

    The number of people using food banks has risen by 1,468%

    Latest figures by the Trussell Trust show that 913,138 adults and children have received three day's emergency food and support from its food banks over 103/14 which is an increase of 346,992 since...

  • Read More

    Support for patients with vulnerabilities with eased pressure on hospitals

    Teams of social workers and NHS staff will soon become available seven days a week under new care plans, reports the BBC.Ministers are predicting that pressures will ease on hospitals from April once...

Responding to the DWP Consultation:  Housing Benefit Reform - Supported Housing "It was well-run, in a good location, and very useful.  I've only one suggestion; as the session went on it would perhaps have been useful for bullet points of general agreement about what should be in the sector response to be displayed and added to as the session went on, maybe on a flip chart. Regarding your response paper, I particularly like the answer you give to question 9.  In fact the general: "if it ain't broke don't fix it" response could be pushed harder." M.P. - Adref Ltd

 

Briefing Signup

 
Quick Contact

Quick contact

Close

Contact us

T 0333 332 1991 (Local rate)

E info@supportsolutions.co.uk