Are GPS tags for Dementia Patients barbaric?

  • The introduction of GPS tags being attached to dementia patients who regularly go missing has been classed as barbaric by campaigners.

    It has been introduced by Sussex police for the tags to be attached to older care patients who are likely to wonder off, as Sussex Police have estimated that one-in-four of more than 300 missing persons inquiries it launched in 2011 involved a dementia patient.

    The Maze 3A number of local authorities are already using similar devices to track sufferers, but this is believed to be the first time a police force has taken on such a scheme.

    The reason they have given is that it will save money on searching for them.It will also reduce the anxiety of families of patients who go missing, and reduce the risk of harm to the patient, but social care campaigners say it just a way to cheapen social care services.

    They say it is a crude form of monitoring as if patients were receiving adequate social care, which includes monitoring, then they would not go missing, and that this is the problem that needs to be fixed.

    To be forced to wear a GPS tag is described as barbaric as it is similar to tags attached to criminals, and is said to be inhumane to treat people suffering with an illness and need care and support in the same way as someone who is being tracked as a punishment for a criminal act. Neil Duncan-Jordan, the national officer of the National Pensioners’ Convention says the device puts patients on par with criminals.

     The tracking device can be worn around patients’ necks, clipped to belts and attached to house keys, and it also has a button to connect to a 24-hour call centre.

    Chief Inspector Tanya Jones said:

    The GPS will be very cost-effective to the police. It will reduce anxiety for the family and really reduce the police time spent on this issue.

    However, Dot Gibson, general secretary of the National Pensioners Convention, does not think this is a good enough reason and accused the police of "trying to get care on the cheap":

    Trying to equate somebody who has committed a criminal act with somebody who is suffering dementia is completely wrong.

    I doubt whether anyone in the Cabinet would want their parents dealt with in this way if they were suffering from dementia.

    It looks at the problem in the wrong way. If you've got people in the community who are so bad that they are wandering off at night and are not safe, they should be properly cared for, they shouldn't be tagged.

    It's a crude form of monitoring when the issue needs a much more detailed response than this.

    The use of GPS devices has also called the patients human rights in to question.

    An East Sussex Conservative councillor, Bill Bentley has pointed out that some patients may not wished to be tracked. He has warned it could see a technological solution imposed on people in a way “that they may or may not wish to have happened”.

    The Alzheimer's Society say:

    In some circumstances and when appropriate consent is given, GPS tracking can enable a person with dementia to remain independent for longer, providing them and their carer with peace of mind.

    But we must balance the potential advantages to the individual and the protection of a person’s civil liberties. Any tracking system must support and never replace good quality care.

    At what point can you leave people with dementia at risk and when do you step in and prevent the risk , even if the method of prevention is used because it is the easiest? When does the prevention stop being a time and money saving idea and become inhuman?

    The best way to think of it is which treatment would you prefer if you had a life changing and confusing illness like dementia?

    Image source:


Related articles

  • Read More

    Adults with vulnerabilities in custody are not receiving appropriate support

    A report commissioned by the Home Office has said that lack of awareness and a shortage of trained volunteers means police often go ahead without on present, reports the BBC.Home Secretary Theresa...

  • Read More

    Chief inspector warns cuts are affecting adult social care

    Andrea Sutcliffe has said that many carers ended up being "the sort of care worker you wouldn't want them to be", reports the BBC.Adult social care budgets have been cut by £4.6bn since 2010 - a 31%...

  • Read More

    Social care services for adults struggling due to budget cuts

    There is a £ shortfall to councils in England warns the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, and freezing care provider fees to save money is no longer sustainable, reports the...

  • Read More

    People with vulnerabilities left at risk by policy makers

    ‘Solutions from the Frontline’, published by a coalition of charities looks into the ideas and experiences of service users. It investigates how the new government along with national and local...

  • Read More

    Social landlords in Wales hope to save the NHS £1.7m

    The savings will come from housing 33 patients under the care of the Aneurin Bevan University health board, through a project called ‘In One Place.' This project places patients who have a mental...

  • Read More

    New supported housing service for people needing care after hospital

    The service will provide supported accommodation for people who no longer need specialist medical care, but who are no longer able to return home due to changes in their home care needs. It is hoped...

  • Read More

    Proposal for an extension on the integration of health and social care in Staffordshire

    Staffordshire County Council wishes to agree on a new deal which will help to improve integration between health and social care for its residents, reports ITV.The deal, if agreed, will extend the...

  • Read More

    Older people and people with disabilities finding it hard to get state funded care

    Social services leaders are warning that many people with disabilities or older people with care needs are facing the challenge of having to pay for their own support at the end of the next...

  • Read More

    The number of people using food banks has risen by 1,468%

    Latest figures by the Trussell Trust show that 913,138 adults and children have received three day's emergency food and support from its food banks over 103/14 which is an increase of 346,992 since...

  • Read More

    Support for patients with vulnerabilities with eased pressure on hospitals

    Teams of social workers and NHS staff will soon become available seven days a week under new care plans, reports the BBC.Ministers are predicting that pressures will ease on hospitals from April once...

Exempt Accommodation, Welfare Reform and Vulnerable Tenants Everything was extremely useful. I like to hear about the updated case law and how things are changing. Also like to hear other delegates examples and the responses to their difficulties. Support solutions are excellent. K.B- Jephson Housing Association


Briefing Signup