Report finds that many adults with vulnerabilities are ‘imprisoned' in their care homes
- 13 Mar
A House of Lords inquiry has found that many safeguards being used to protect adults with vulnerabilities are actually oppressing those who lack the mental capacity and end up forcing decisions upon them.
In the worst cases of the House of Lords investigation, safeguards were being used to oppress people and force decisions on them. They found that these measures, which are supposed to be used to look after at-risk patients, were actually being used to deprive them wrongly of their liberty, reports the Guardian.
The House of Lords committee was set up to investigate how mental health reforms introduced in 2005 are working and have said they are concerned that deprivation of liberty safeguards and that they should be removed and new systems drawn up from scratch.
The safeguards are part of the wider Mental Capacity Act which have been drawn up to simplify how patients who lack capacity are dealt with and to "empower, protect and support" them.
The report also found that social workers, healthcare professionals and others involved in the care of people with vulnerabilities were not aware of the act and failed to implement it.
The committee chairman, Lord Hardie, said: "We were very concerned by what we heard about the safeguards. The evidence suggests that tens of thousands of people are being deprived of their liberty without the protection of the law, and without the protection that parliament intended. Worse still, in some cases the safeguards are being wilfully used to oppress individuals and to force decisions upon them, regardless of what actions may be in their best interests. The criticism of the safeguards extended to the legislative provisions themselves; we were told the provisions were poorly drafted, overly complex and bureaucratic. A senior judge described the experience of trying to write a judgment on the safeguards as feeling 'as if you have been in a washing machine and spin dryer'. Even if implementation could be improved, the legislation itself is flawed. In the face of such criticism, the only option is to start again. The government needs to go back to the drawing board to draft replacement provisions that are easy to understand and implement, and in keeping with the style and ethos of the Mental Capacity Act. When the act came into being, it was seen as a visionary piece of legislation, which marked a turning point in the rights of vulnerable people; those with learning difficulties, dementia, brain injuries or temporary impairment. The committee is unanimous that this is important legislation, with the potential to transform lives. However, what is clear from the substantial volume of evidence we have received is that the act is not working at all well. That is because people do not know about the act, or do not understand it, even though many professionals have legal obligations under it. Those who may lack capacity have legal rights under the act, but they are not being fulfilled. In many cases complying with the act is treated like an optional add-on - nice to have, but not essential. In short, the act is not being implemented. The committee believes that the act is good and it needs to be implemented. What we want to see is a change in attitudes and practice across the health and social care sector which reflects the empowering ethos of the act."
A Ministry of Justice spokesman said "more needs to be done" to make the 2005 legislation "is more widely understood".
"We welcome the select committee's report. This is an important piece of legislation", the spokesman said. "The Ministry of Justice and the Department of Health will consider the House of Lords' report in detail and we will publish a full response in due course."
What do you think of this? Tweet us your comments @suppsolutions
Image source: http://www.sxc.hu/photo/982475
- 26 Aug
Adults with vulnerabilities in custody are not receiving appropriate support
A report commissioned by the Home Office has said that lack of awareness and a shortage of trained volunteers means police often go ahead without on present, reports the BBC.Home Secretary Theresa...
- 11 Aug
Chief inspector warns cuts are affecting adult social care
Andrea Sutcliffe has said that many carers ended up being "the sort of care worker you wouldn't want them to be", reports the BBC.Adult social care budgets have been cut by £4.6bn since 2010 - a 31%...
- 04 Jun
Social care services for adults struggling due to budget cuts
There is a £1.1.bn shortfall to councils in England warns the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, and freezing care provider fees to save money is no longer sustainable, reports the...
- 03 Jun
People with vulnerabilities left at risk by policy makers
‘Solutions from the Frontline’, published by a coalition of charities looks into the ideas and experiences of service users. It investigates how the new government along with national and local...
- 20 Apr
Social landlords in Wales hope to save the NHS £1.7m
The savings will come from housing 33 patients under the care of the Aneurin Bevan University health board, through a project called ‘In One Place.' This project places patients who have a mental...
- 17 Apr
New supported housing service for people needing care after hospital
The service will provide supported accommodation for people who no longer need specialist medical care, but who are no longer able to return home due to changes in their home care needs. It is hoped...
- 15 Apr
Proposal for an extension on the integration of health and social care in Staffordshire
Staffordshire County Council wishes to agree on a new deal which will help to improve integration between health and social care for its residents, reports ITV.The deal, if agreed, will extend the...
- 17 Mar
Older people and people with disabilities finding it hard to get state funded care
Social services leaders are warning that many people with disabilities or older people with care needs are facing the challenge of having to pay for their own support at the end of the next...
- 11 Nov
The number of people using food banks has risen by 1,468%
Latest figures by the Trussell Trust show that 913,138 adults and children have received three day's emergency food and support from its food banks over 103/14 which is an increase of 346,992 since...
- 30 Oct
Support for patients with vulnerabilities with eased pressure on hospitals
Teams of social workers and NHS staff will soon become available seven days a week under new care plans, reports the BBC.Ministers are predicting that pressures will ease on hospitals from April once...
Exempt Accommodation, Welfare Reform and Vulnerable Tenants Everything was extremely useful. I like to hear about the updated case law and how things are changing. Also like to hear other delegates examples and the responses to their difficulties. Support solutions are excellent. K.B- Jephson Housing Association