Disabled people are seeing no benefit from Right to Control pilots

  • Disabled people trialling the Right to Control pilots found that there was no increase of choice or quality of life and found they were being undermined by inadequate support planning.

    An evaluation has found that government pilots put in place to provide disabled people with personal budgets that integrate a number of funding streams has failed to deliver any actual benefit to those trialling it. The research failed to find any evidence that the Right to Control pilots had had any positive impact on disabled people, in terms of experiences in applying for and organising servicers, nor in their everyday lives.

    Right to Control was designed to enable disabled people to pool resources from up to six funding streams - adult social care, Supporting People, Independent Living FundDisabled Facilities GrantWork Choice and Access to Work - and exercise choice and control over how the combined budget was spent. It was tested in seven trailblazer areas: Barnet, Essex, Leicester, Manchester, Newham, Greater Manchester, Sheffield and Barnsley, and parts of Surrey, starting in 2010 and running until December 2013.

    The research was taken from the outcomes of 1,624 people in trailblazer areas with a comparison group of 1,658 disabled people in face-to-face interviews from late last year.

    One of Right to Control's main objectives was to improve choice and control however only 29% of clients in Right to Control areas said they had "as much control as they wanted" over their daily lives, compared to 31% in the comparison group.

    A suggested reason for the lack of impact of Right to Control is that many users found they received the same service as they had done before.

    It was also found that the quality of support planning "varied considerably" across the trailblazers, and many clients felt that they were limited in exploring alternatives sources of support.

    Right to Control was said to be most effective when:

    -       Staff told disabled people clearly that they could make changes to their support.

    -       Disabled people received a meaningful choice of provision and information to help them make informed choices.

    -       Help was given to disabled people in arranging their support.

    In its disability strategy published last month, the government said it was considering the evaluation findings and would announce whether it planned to roll out Right to Control in due course.

    Image source: http://www.morguefile.com/archive/display/71078

Related articles

  • Read More

    Young people with learning disabilities more likely to be abused

    A group of children’s charities have said that young people with disabilities have the “same vulnerabilities” as all young people but face extra “barriers” to getting protection or support,...

  • Read More

    Success for a disability sport programme

    The programme ran for three weeks and included multi-sport camps at Aberdeen Sports Village, reports the Mearns Leader. Chair of Aberdeenshire Council’s Education, Learning and Leisure Committee...

  • Read More

    Hartlepool to open a disability centre

    Work has begun on the Hartlepool Borough Council project which aims to provide the Centre for Independent Living on the site of the current Havelock Centre in Burbank, reports The Hartlepool Mail.It...

  • Read More

    Reform for care of adults with learning disabilities criticised for being slow

    Following the care home abuse scandal at Winterbourne, Sir Stephen Bubb headed a review into care home abuse, which was published in November, reports the BBC.England's chief nursing officer said...

  • Read More

    Campaigners warn that people with disabilities are losing rights due to government cuts

    Charities are concerned that the rights of people with learning disabilities to live independent lives are slipping due to government cuts to benefits and social care, reports the Guardian. A letter...

  • Read More

    Concern over disability benefits following council change

    On the 30th of June a £500m Independent Living Fund will be in the control of local authorities, leaving people fearing how the benefit allowance for disabled adults will be affected, reports the...

  • Read More

    Victims of disability hate crime are being let down

    Police, prosecutors and probations services have failed to bring in need change over the past two years, a report by the Criminal Justice Inspectorate has found, reports the BBC.The CPS, police and...

  • Read More

    New initiative to support young people with disabilities

    Liberty Staffordshire Community Interest Company have been developed to maximise opportunities for young people due to growing concern they could be left isolated following the withdrawal of...

  • Read More

    How technology is helping people with disabilities

    At the exhibit people presented all-terrain wheelchairs, adapted smartphone for people whose fingers can't cope with normal devices, wheelchairs that allow the user to become level with the people...

  • Read More

    Charities call for action on accessible housing

    Leonard Cheshire Disability charity has told The Yorkshire Post that the lack of housing which is accessible for people with disabilities must become and election issue and is calling for the...

Briefing Signup