"More welfare cuts will not reduce people's dependency on the state"

  • Blog by Joseph Rowntree Foundation on reducing benefits:

    Cutting benefits for groups who receive little public sympathy may make for a good Conference speech, but it risks increasing poverty and hardship.

    And unless there is a follow up 'master plan' for creating more and better jobs, massively increasing access to them and sorting out the housing crisis it's not likely to do as much as those advocating further cuts are hoping to reduce the deficit or people's dependency on the state.

    There were no big surprises in the welfare cuts proposals made by George Osborne and Iain Duncan Smith today. The core intentions seem pretty clear:

    • Welfare will be cut by a further £10 billion, on top of the £18 billion announced earlier. 
    • The new cuts will come exclusively from benefits for working-age people, not from universal benefits for pensioners.  
    • Two groups are in the firing line:
      - Out-of-work families
      - Young people on housing benefit 

    The recent British Social Attitudes survey showed that these kinds of cuts may well be in line with public opinion as views have hardened towards perceived 'benefits scrounger'.

    However, the proposals are driven by more than this. They reflect a set of underlying beliefs about people's choices and motivations:  

    • Young people can and should live at home until they are earning enough to buy or rent somewhere else to live.  
    • People who are out of work could be in work if they tried hard enough.  
    • People have absolute control over their reproduction; poor people who have more than an unspecified number of children are making an irresponsible lifestyle choice. 

    At the risk of ducking some fun arguments on Twitter, it's the evidence behind the first two that I want to question right now.

    Both are true in some cases: some young people could stay living at home and some people who are out of work could get a job. However, the evidence suggests that they are not true for a great many people.

    Earlier this year Kathleen Kelly blogged about the idea of removing housing benefit from the under-25s. She highlighted the housing crisis that is facing young people in 2020 and the youth homelessness that's driven by relationship breakdown. Our research shows that the assumption that most young people receiving housing benefit could happily and safely live with Mum and Dad until they get a stable, decently paid job and move into a basic but adequate shared flat is a world away from the lives of many poor, young people.

    Our evidence also shows that many people out of work do desperately want jobs but can't find them. This is reinforced by the statistics on underemployment - 6 million people want to work more but can't. It also demonstrates that just 'getting a job' isn't the whole point: millions are trapped in a cycle of poorly paid, insecure work and unemployment, with little prospect of breaking into better jobs. Getting a job is still the best route out of poverty. But these kinds of jobs aren't a very good route. When someone in a family in poverty gets a job, only 56% are lifted out of poverty.

    We are hoping to address these issues with a new programme to develop a UK-wide anti-poverty strategy based on the best evidence across all the areas that contribute to poverty. Maybe it'll catch on.

    8/10/12 by Joseph Rowntree Foundation




Related articles

  • Read More


    SNP Housing Minister, Kevin Stewart said the following while commenting on Social Security and Equalities in the Scottish Parliament, SCN reports:"These figures demonstrate Scotland's strong...

  • Read More


    Joanna Cox, a manager of Chandos Lodge, said:"Food is a huge factor in our residents' lives and we want to ensure the meals we provide not only satisfy their tastes but benefit their health."Healthy...

  • Read More


    Although, many integration initiatives have been introduced across the NHS; For example, vanguard sites to the prime minister's Challenge Fund and integrated care pioneers- many involving GP...

  • Read More


    The findings show that landlords are evenly split, with 35% intending to vote leave and 35% intending to vote to remain, reports Housing Excellence.According to Richard Lambert, the NLA's Chief...

  • Read More

    Highest records of working families since 1996

    Research has also shown that parents of young children, who were part of a couple, were almost twice as likely to be in a job. In comparison to older mothers, young mothers under 24 were only half as...

  • Read More

    What percentage of people have mental disorders in the UK?

    Percentage of adults suffering from common mental disorders:Prevalence of common mental disorders:Women (19.7%) are significantly more likely to experience common mental health disorders than men...

  • Read More

    Safe Tweets, safe Twitter

    Twitter is one of the most popular platforms where users across the globe collectively contribute 500 million Tweets every day. However, it can sometimes be inevitable that you come across content...

  • Read More

    Google Creates System to Eradicate Child Abuse Images

    Pressure was on the company to do something about the problem after it emerged that men convicted of murdering Tia Sharp, aged 12, and April Jones, aged 5, had been viewing the indecent images online...

  • Read More

    How Councils Can Improve Home Care

    Read the full article at Community Care.Southwark council has agreed in principle to Unison's ethical home care charter and is working with local providers to find out how they could raise pay ...

  • Read More

    Man Aged 83 is First Reported Assisted Suicide for Dementia

    Reported @ BBC News | Health on 31/5/13He was assessed as mentally competent to make the decision at the centre in Switzerland, as he was only in the first stages of the disease.He did not want to...

The Welfare Reform Act: Universal Credit, Sheltered and Supported Housing The content was concise and to the point. The content was relevant to our service, and gave us a better us a better indication of were stand with upcoming changes. Rosie Kaur - Panahghar


Briefing Signup